Having used project management tools for 13 years, I have found they each miss something major. This one is missing the estimate/actual budget element which is critical to small businesses. Entire departments can be eliminated if they cannot prove that they deliver projects on budget.
Microsoft Project never handled it well through version 2003 Enterprise either and depended on another application to do it any justice. Just keep in mind the balancing act that all PM's must do well at to survive: manage scope, budget, and schedule.
We are evalutating this now for use corporate wide as a contractor/integrator, but we need to be able to track time against budget by task & milestone. Has anyone developed a module to do this yet or has Active Collab been working on this to include in a release? Please let me know as this affects whether or not we will be able to use Active Collab.
FWIW, Planning module for activeCollab allows you to estimate time for tasks, milestones, tickets, checklists and pages. You can the use activeCollab's time tracking feature to add time to these items. Coming back to Planning module will show you the actual vs estimated time for each item.
It will even total up the estimates / actual times.
We use your reports module and my only issue holding us back from the planning module is flash, which does not allow use to extend the extension as needed. We to are open to collaborating on a module of this type, as it is greatly needed. It is probably what will most like turn us away from activeCollab as a replacement for daylite.
We are due for renew and will not be renewing this year after 4 years with you and are going to have to head to a different software provider if we cannot get this feature added really soon (like the next 2-3 weeks).
As our company has grown, we need much better methods of time tracking and billing. Tracking employees time throughout the day to AC is all fine but could still be better, look at getharvest.com for example. Billing from AC is terrible and the invoicing module is so basic it shouldn't have been released yet.
Take a look at worlflowmax.com. Their interface is shithouse but the functionality is much better that AC's is to date. They also just released a good job scheduling interface that is quite impressive.
We are glad to hear that you business has grown significantly in the past years. What I miss in your message are exact problems (not features or competing products) that you are experiencing with current activeCollab feature set. What problems would you like activeCollab to be address in the upcoming releases?
PS: Our goal with activeCollab was never to include every feature imaginable or available in the competing products, but create a well balanced project collaboration product with just the right amount of picked features.
We need to be able to do the following in our business:
- Analyse a project on a milestone level to see how profitable the project was.
- Simplify our billing to clients on a time and materials basis.
Our problems with AC would be fixed with the following added functionality (much of this functionality is available in workflowmax):
Add activity/task management module to AC (e.g. Web Design - Wireframes, Web Design - Concepts, Web Development - front end programming, Web Development - deployment). This would enable us to add our own export functionality to MYOB so that we could streamline the invoice creation for on-going clients whom we invoice on a time and materials basis for each month.
Add tasks to a project with descriptions. e.g. Web Development - Backend Programming - "product module".
Add cost and time estimates and/or fixed budgets to tasks on a project basis, enabling project reporting against time budgets per task.
Add ability for users select which activity they were completing when entering time records against a project.
Currently in active collab we are unable to log time to a set of pre-defined activities/tasks. We would like to be able to add a list of tasks into AC for selection at the time entry point. These activities/tasks would be matched against time estimates or fixed costs that we enter per task per project. This would basically be a copy of our quote for a client, entered into AC. Then we could export the time entries and import them into our accounting platform (MYOB) for billing.
To handle our ongoing work and adhoc updates that we do for clients we would have a project for every client called "Adhoc Services" and we would log our time against our tasks/activities to this project and we would generate our monthly on-going invoices from this data.
We would happily build major components if you can delegate which areas you would need to complete and which we would complete to help get this out the door asap.
Thank you so much in advance. We do love your software and hope we can work together to get these features.
We don't have plans to move activeCollab 3 in that direction, sorry. Initial release will definitely not have task estimates and project budgets, but we'll consider these features in the future (no promises though). Concept of "activity" is something that I can't quite wrap my mind around (maybe I just need more info to better understand it), so I doubt we are working on anything similar :)
If you need budgeting and estimates, we recommend that you consider building these features in as a module instead of waiting for us to add it.
Microsoft Project never handled it well through version 2003 Enterprise either and depended on another application to do it any justice. Just keep in mind the balancing act that all PM's must do well at to survive: manage scope, budget, and schedule.